Chocolate Covered Nutter Butter Cookie Flip Flops

Sharing is caring!

What if the cutest thing at your pool party this summer wasn’t a floatie, a playlist, or even the snack table — but a cookie? These nutter butter cookie flip flops are the no bake summer dessert you didn’t know your life was missing. Chocolate-covered Nutter Butter cookies get dipped, decorated, and dolled up into the most adorable tiny flip flops you’ve ever seen — and the best part? Zero oven required. Whether you’re throwing a beach birthday party, a backyard pool party, or just need a fun summer snack to keep the kids entertained, these easy, simple treats deliver maximum cuteness with minimal effort.

This posts contains affiliate links, which means I may earn a commission if you purchase something from my link (at no additional cost to you). Thanks for your support!

I’m a sucker for a good themed treat, and these simple no bake cookies never fail to get that reaction. The bright tropical colors, the teeny flower sprinkles, the little candy straps — it all comes together into something that looks like it took way more effort than it actually did.

Nutter Butter Cookie Flip Flops

Not only are these cookies a fun party treat, they’re also a great activity to do with kids. They can help dip, they can press in the sprinkles, they can definitely “taste test” the leftover candy melts. It’s a win-win. Line them up on a serving tray by color and watch them disappear faster than sunscreen at the beach.

One of the biggest perks of this easy no bake treat is the ingredient list — it’s refreshingly short. No fancy equipment, no obscure pantry items, just a handful of colorful supplies and a bag of Nutter Butters. Here’s what you’ll need:

• Nutter Butter cookies — The peanut-butter sandwich shape is basically a flip flop waiting to happen. Nature knew what it was doing.
• Pink, light blue, yellow, and orange melting candy — Bold, summery colors that make these cookies impossible to ignore on a dessert tray.
• Flower sprinkles — The tiny finishing touch that takes these from “cute cookie” to “actual flip flop.”

Check the recipe card below for exact measurements and full instructions.

Flip Flop Nutter Butters

No baking, no stress, and no culinary degree required — here’s how to pull these off like a pro.

Working one color at a time, melt each candy in a separate microwave-safe bowl following the package directions. Stir frequently — candy melts can go from smooth to scorched fast if you’re not paying attention.

Spoon a small amount of each melted color into its own piping bag and set aside. These will become the decorative straps later.

One by one, dip each Nutter Butter in the melted candy until fully coated. Use a fork to take the cookie out of the melted candy, then tap the fork gently against the bowl’s edge to shake off any extra coating.

Transfer each dipped cookie to a parchment-lined baking sheet. Repeat until you have six cookies per color. Let them cool until the coating is fully hardened.

When the chocolate on your cookies has hardened, warm up the piping bags slightly if the candy has gotten hard. Snip a tiny opening at the tip of each bag, then pipe a V-shape across the top of each cookie. That V is your flip flop strap — keep the lines clean and thin for the best look.

Before the strap hardens, press a single flower sprinkle right into the center of the V. This is the part that makes everyone go “Awww.” Don’t skip it.

Let them set completely before serving, stacking, or sneaking one for yourself.

Nutter Butter Flip Flop Cookie Ideas

Since this simple flip flop cookie recipe is so easy to make, you can easily change it up to suit your needs. Try these simple ideas for a new version of this beachy treat idea.

The real magic of these easy no bake summer treats is how endlessly customizable they are. Once you’ve got the basic technique down, the creative possibilities are wide open.

• Swap colors to match any party theme — think tropical brights for a luau or soft pinks for a birthday.
• Use white chocolate or almond bark in place of candy melts for a slightly richer flavor.
• Trade flower sprinkles for stars, hearts, seashells, or whatever sprinkle matches your vibe.
• Add edible glitter to the coating for a sparkly, beachy shimmer effect.
• Go neon for a high-energy pool party dessert table that practically glows.
• Make holiday flip flops with red and green candy for a fun Christmas in July beach-themed snack.

Flip Flop Cookie FAQs

Can I use different candy melt colors? Absolutely — this recipe is made to be customized. Go neon for a pool party, pastels for a baby shower, or red and green for a Christmas in July situation. The flip flop format works with any color palette.

Can I make these ahead of time? Yes, and you should! These simple no bake cookies actually hold up beautifully for a day or two in advance. Make them the night before, store them in an airtight container, and you’re set for party day without any last-minute stress.

Do I need actual piping bags? Not at all. A small zip-top bag with the corner snipped off works just as well. The key is a tiny opening — you want control, not a flood of candy.

Can kids help make these? Kids were basically born to make this recipe. Dipping, pressing sprinkles, decorating straps — it’s all fair game. Just expect some candy melt on hands, counters, and possibly the dog.

What if I can’t find flower sprinkles? No stress. Small candy pearls, mini hearts, star sprinkles, or even a single round nonpareil all look adorable in the strap. Use whatever makes your flip flop sing.

How do I keep the chocolate coating smooth? Stir often and don’t overheat. If the candy starts to thicken up as you work, a tiny drop of vegetable oil stirred in will bring it right back to a dippable consistency.

Can I use white chocolate instead of candy melts? Yes! Melted white chocolate tinted with gel food coloring works great. Just note that white chocolate can be a little trickier to work with temperature-wise, so keep it gently warm throughout.

Storage Instructions

Store finished treats in an airtight container at room temperature for up to three days. If you’re stacking them, slip a piece of wax paper between layers to keep the icing from becoming one with the treat below it. Want to get even further ahead? Freeze the undecorated treats for up to a month, thaw completely, and then add your icing and sharks before serving.

More Beach Party Ideas:

Graham Cracker Beach Snack for a Party

Easy Beach Cake

Pool Party Cupcakes

Cute Beach Cookies for a Party