No Bake Nutter Butter Turkey Cookies for Thanksgiving

Sharing is caring!

Searching for a cute, fun, and easy Thanksgiving dessert that kids absolutely love, these no bake turkey cookies are the perfect treat! Made with simple ingredients like Nutter Butters, candy melts, and M&Ms, this quick cookie idea is a great way to get little hands involved in the kitchen. Whether you’re hosting a school party, planning Thanksgiving snacks, or just looking for the best turkey cookie recipe to decorate with your kids, these adorable treats come together in minutes.

This posts contains affiliate links, which means I may earn a commission if you purchase something from my link (at no additional cost to you). Thanks for your support!

These adorable no bake turkey cookies are made with Nutter Butters and decorated with candy melts to create bright, colorful candy feathers your kids will love. They’re an easy Thanksgiving dessert idea that you can make ahead, pack for school parties, or serve as a fun holiday snack.

Thanksgiving Cookie Recipe

These no bake holiday cookies are a kid favorite because they’re as fun to decorate as they are to eat. Since the entire recipe is made from store-bought ingredients, they’re simple enough for kids to assemble on their own with just a little bit of help from an adult.

The candy melts harden quickly, so you can decorate a whole batch fast—perfect for parties or last-minute Thanksgiving dessert ideas. And because they’re made from Nutter Butters, these turkey cookies are already packed with delicious sweet-and-salty peanut butter flavor, making them irresistible for all ages.

There’s no baking involved in making these easy sweet snacks! And the best part is that you can put them together with just a few simple ingredients. Here’s what you’ll need to make these adorable Thanksgiving treats:

• Nutter Butters: The large cookie forms the turkey body and gives that classic peanut butter cookie texture.
• Nutter Butter Bites: These mini cookies make the cute little turkey head.
• Yellow, Orange & Red Candy Melts: Melt and pipe these to create colorful feathers, attach the pieces of the body together, and decorate the faces.
• Candy Eyes: A must for adorable turkey expressions!
• Yellow M&Ms or Reese’s Pieces: These form the turkey’s beak and add a pop of color.

How to Make Thanksgiving Cookies

These cookies come together quickly—perfect for little helpers! Here’s how to decorate your own Thanksgiving treats:

The first step to melt your candy coating. Melt each color of candy melts separately according to the package directions. Transfer each melted color to its own piping bag and snip off a small portion of the tip.

After that, you can assemble your turkey bodies. Pipe a small amount of any melted candy color at the bottom end of a Nutter Butter cookie. Gently stick a mini Nutter Butter on top to form the turkey’s head. Allow this to set for a few minutes.

Next, let’s make the turkey’s feathers! Above the turkey head, pipe feather shapes using the yellow, orange, and red candy melts. You can make long feathers, short feathers, wavy feathers—whatever your kids think is fun!

After that, you can add the faces to your turkey cookies. Use a tiny dot of melted yellow candy to attach two candy eyes. Add another small dot to secure a yellow M&M or Reese’s Pieces for the turkey beak.

The last step to decorating your cute cookie is to use the red candy melt to pipe a small wattle under the beak.

Turkey Cookie Recipe Ideas

With their bright colors, cute candy faces, and totally no-bake prep, these turkey cookies are the perfect simple Thanksgiving treat for kids and adults alike. They make any party, classroom celebration, or holiday dessert table instantly more fun—and you’ll love how easy they are to decorate.

And the best part about making them is that these cookies are super customizable! Try these fun and decorating ideas:

• Make them with Oreos: You can easily swap out the Nutter Butters with Oreo cookies. Use full-sized Oreos for the body and mini Oreos for the head.
• Use chocolate chips: Don’t have any candy eyes on hand? Swap the candy eyes for mini chocolate chips.
• Skip the piping and use candy corn: While the piping is pretty simple on these cookies, if you don’t think your kids are up to the task, you can decorate your cookies with candy corn feathers instead of the chocolate decorations.
• Use tweezers for easy decorating. Add the candy eyes and beak using tweezers to make it easier to transfer the small pieces to the top of the cookies.
• Grab some zip-top bags. Out of piping bags? Use a zip-top plastic storage bag instead. Just fill the bag with the melted chocolate and cut the top off the corner to decorate.

Thanksgiving Turkey Cookie FAQs

Are turkey cookies gluten free?

Classic Nutter Butters are not gluten free. If you need a GF version, substitute with gluten free sandwich cookies, like gluten free Golden Oreos.

Can I make these turkey cookies ahead of time?

Yes! These no bake cookies keep very well. Make them 1–2 days in advance and store in an airtight container. Make sure to place a piece of parchment paper between layers to keep the candy from sticking together.

How do I store turkey cookies?

Keep them at room temperature in a sealed container for up to 5 days. Avoid refrigeration—the cookies can soften.

Can I use frosting instead of candy melts?

Yes! Buttercream or store-bought frosting works great for attaching the pieces, though feathers will not harden like candy melts.

More Easy Recipe Ideas:

Cute Thanksgiving Dessert: Mini Turkey Pudding Pies

Oreo Turkeys

Sweet and Salty Kitchen Sink Thanksgiving Cookie Recipe

Turkey Cinnamon Rolls